Court rules U.S. copyright chief should be reinstated after Trump's firing
UPI

Court rules U.S. copyright chief should be reinstated after Trump's firing

Shira Perlmutter is to be reinstated to her role at the Library of Congress as register of copyrights under the legislative branch, the D.C. U.S. Court of Appeals ruled.

Sept. 10 (UPI) -- A federal appeals court ruled Wednesday that Shira Perlmutter be reinstated to her role under the legislative branch at the Library of Congress as register of copyrights.

The D.C. U.S. Court of Appeals ruling comes after Perlmutter was dismissed by U.S. President Donald Trump just days after Trump had removed Librarian of Congress Carla Hayden in May, only to replace her with U.S. Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche.

"Because Perlmutter leads an agency that is housed in the Legislative Branch and her primary role is to advise Congress, Perlmutter's situation differs significantly from the Executive Branch officials whose removals have been repeatedly upheld," Judges Florence Pan and J. Michelle Childs, both appointees of President Joe Biden, wrote Wednesday in their decision.

U.S. law dictates that the president appoint a Senate-confirmed Librarian of Congress, who in turn appoints the register of copyrights.

Pan said that removing Perlmutter was, she wrote in the 26-page ruling, a "violation of the separation of powers that is significantly different in kind and in degree from the cases that have come before."

In his dissent, the Trump-appointed Judge Justin Walker sided with the administration and cited Trump's gutting of U.S. labor board members.

"Recently, repeatedly, and unequivocally, the Supreme Court has stayed lower-court injunctions that barred the President from removing officers exercising executive power," he wrote on Wednesday.

U.S. Rep. Joe Morelle, the ranking Democrat on the Committee on House Administration, called Perlmutter's dismissal at the time a "brazen, unprecedented power grab with no legal basis."

The case is likely to be appealed by the White House to a higher court bench.

Recommended for You

Texas drops lawsuit against doctor accused of illegally providing care to transgender youth
AP News

Texas drops lawsuit against doctor accused of illegally providing care to transgender youth

News
‘Person of interest’ in custody in fatal shooting of Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk
Los Angeles Times

‘Person of interest’ in custody in fatal shooting of Turning Point USA founder Charlie Kirk

News
An activist flotilla on a mission to Gaza says it was attacked again in Tunisia
AP News

An activist flotilla on a mission to Gaza says it was attacked again in Tunisia

News
4 students, including suspect, injured amid Colorado school shooting
UPI

4 students, including suspect, injured amid Colorado school shooting

News
Trump takes one step back and another forward in his attempt to reshape the Fed
AP News

Trump takes one step back and another forward in his attempt to reshape the Fed

News
Kirk started media career as radio host, a traditional route for emerging conservative voices
Los Angeles Times

Kirk started media career as radio host, a traditional route for emerging conservative voices

News
South Korea group to help Chipotle expand into Southeast Asia
UPI

South Korea group to help Chipotle expand into Southeast Asia

News
NFL: Washington Commanders defeat New York Giants
UPI

NFL: Washington Commanders defeat New York Giants

News
Schiff lawyer told Justice Department it should investigate Pulte for probing mortgages of Trump opponents
Los Angeles Times

Schiff lawyer told Justice Department it should investigate Pulte for probing mortgages of Trump opponents

News
French president names new prime minister in wake of government collapse
UPI

French president names new prime minister in wake of government collapse

News
Schiff lawyer told Justice Department it should investigate Pulte for probing mortgages of Trump opponents
Los Angeles Times

Schiff lawyer told Justice Department it should investigate Pulte for probing mortgages of Trump opponents

News
NASA urges public to book Artemis II space flight 'boarding pass' soon
UPI

NASA urges public to book Artemis II space flight 'boarding pass' soon

News
Inmate deaths and grim conditions in L.A. County jails prompt state lawsuit
Los Angeles Times

Inmate deaths and grim conditions in L.A. County jails prompt state lawsuit

News
Aaron Judge hits 359th career homer, passing Hall of Famer Yogi Berra for 5th in Yankees history
AP News

Aaron Judge hits 359th career homer, passing Hall of Famer Yogi Berra for 5th in Yankees history

News
Democrats seek information on Trump administration's security clearance revocations
AP News

Democrats seek information on Trump administration's security clearance revocations

News